As someone normally highly critical of the Israeli justice system, it is a surprising pleasure to be able to agree whole-heartedly with the High Court’s recent decision with regard to Arabs. Yes, all Israeli citizens should support the Israeli state, regardless of ethnicity or religion. Given the neighborhood we live in, a strong IDF is not optional, it’s essential. There are obvious problems with enforcing a universal military draft; imprisonment or other legal punishments for those who refuse or fail to serve is not practical, particularly when the number of draft dodgers are large. In general women are not psychologically or physically suitable for active combat, but often are willing to contribute in various supporting roles. Arabs, who may well be loyal citizens, might reasonably be reluctant to fight against combatants who are also Arabs, and might even be close relatives. However, the state already offers the option of other forms of national service,which are beneficial to the population at large. This option is available to every citizen. For those who, for whatever reason other than physical or mental disability, refuse to serve in any capacity should lose all future benefits, such as child allowance, that are available to Israeli citizens.
Discrimination either for or against any group or individual on the basis of race, religion sex of any category is against the principles on which the state was founded and either is or should be illegal; it is obviously unfair, and the High Court is justified in criticising it. My only caveat is for the Court asking the government to explain the policy; I would have preferred for the Court to be firmer and simply declare the discrimination illegal.
stephenscohen.com 